Skip to main content
Write a Review, Win $500! Help guests by leaving a review of your favorite dishes. Be entered in a drawing to win $500 on 3/1.
Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery
  • ORDER NOW ORDER NOW
  • Our Menus
  • Daily Specials
  • Careers
  • Contact
pizza

Food Menu

Become a VIPReceive updates on special events, new menu items, menu reviews, and more!

Food Menu

Appetizers

Baked Clams
00000

Baked Clams

$126 Clams Stuffed with Italian Seasoning

00000
00000

Calamari (Picante)

$13Our Amazing Fried Calamari Tossed with Spicy Peppers, Celery, and Carrots

00000
Sausage & Peppers
00000

Sausage & Peppers

$12Our Homemade Italian Sausage with Red and Green Peppers

00000
00000

Chicken Tenders (Buffalo)

$8deep fried chicken strips tossed in buffalo sauce with ranch dipping sauce

00000
00000

Regular Nachos

$10

00000
Breaded Ravioli
00000

Breaded Ravioli

$11Italian Breaded Cheese Ravioli Deep Fried and Served with Marinara.

00000
00000

Wisconsin Cheese Curds

$8Fried White Cheddar Cheese Curds

00000
00000

Combo Platter

$16Popcorn Shrimp, Fried Calamari, Cheese Curds, & Buffalo Wings Served with Cocktail, Marinara, & Ranch Dipping Sauce.

00000
00000

Cheddar Broccoli Bites

$7smooth cheddar blended with fresh chopped broccoli

00000
Calamari (Fried)
00000

Calamari (Fried)

$12Fried: Traditional with Cocktail Dipping Sauce.

00000
00000

Buffalo Shrimp

$11Jumbo Shrimp Tossed in Spicy Buffalo Sauce and Served with Ranch

00000
00000

Chicken Tenders

$8deep fried chicken strips served with ranch or BBQ dipping sauce

00000
00000

Pulled Pork Nachos

$11traditional nachos topped with tender hand-pulled BBQ pork, tomatoes, green onions. drizzled with ranch

00000
Nacho Fries
10010

Nacho Fries

Waffle Fries Topped with Melted Cheese, Tomatoes, Bacon, Green Onion, Ground Beef, Guacamole, and Sour Cream.1/2 Order $8Full Order $11

10010
Pretzel Bread Sticks
00000

Pretzel Bread Sticks

$10Four Bavarian Pretzel Sticks Served with Your Choice of Cheddar Cheese or Honey Mustard Dipping Sauce

00000
00000

Spinach & Artichoke Dip

$10Homemade Artichoke and Cheese Dip Served with Tortilla Chips.

00000
Fried Cauliflower
00000

Fried Cauliflower

$7Fried Cauliflower Pieces with Ranch Dipping Sauce. Served Plain or Drizzled with Buffalo Sauce

00000
00000

Cheddar Jalapeño Bites

$7cheddar cheese blended with spicy pickled jalapenos

00000

Salads & Soups

Make any Salad a Wrap! Ask your Server about our Daily Specials

Magoo's Special Salad
00000

Magoo's Special Salad

$12Iceberg Lettuce, Salami, Mortadella, Ham, Provolone Cheese, Tomatoes, Pepperoncini, and Black Olives Tossed in Italian Dressing.

00000
Spicy Buffalo Chicken Salad
00000

Spicy Buffalo Chicken Salad

$11Crisp Greens Tossed with Celery, Bleu Cheese, Tomatoes, Onions, Ranch, & Spicy Chicken Strips (Grilled or Breaded).

00000
Santa Fe Salad
00000

Santa Fe Salad

$11Marinated Chicken Breast, Fresh Corn, Black Beans, Shredded Cheese, Tomatoes, Mixed Greens Served with Southwest Ranch Dressing.

00000
Caprese Salad
00000

Caprese Salad

$9Beefsteak Tomatoes, Fresh Mozzarella and Basil - Drizzled with Olive Oil

00000
00000

Soup of the Day

Cup $4Bowl $5

00000
00000

Cobb Salad

$11Grilled Chicken Breast, Avocado, Bleu Cheese, Bacon, Tomatoes, Egg and Mixed Greens Served with Our Homemade Vinaigrette.

00000
00000

Chopped Salad

$11Crisp Lettuce Topped with Ditialini Pasta, Chicken, Bacon, Bleu Cheese and Diced Tomatoes. Tossed in Our House Dressing.

00000
Chicken Caesar
00000

Chicken Caesar

$12Romaine Tossed with Our House Caesar Dressing and Garlic Croutons.

00000
00000

Homemade Minestrone Soup

Cup $4Bowl $5

00000
Chili
00000

Chili

Real Meaty Texas Style Chili Topped with Cheddar and OnionsCup $5Bowl $6

00000

Salerno's Pizza

Begins with traditional Italian thick crust, tomato sauce & cheese. Add your favorite toppings.


Thin and extra thin crust available upon request.

Small 10 Inch - Make your Own Pizza
00000

Small 10 Inch - Make your Own Pizza

$10Traditional Thick Crust, Tomato Sauce and Cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000
00000

Small 10 Inch (Cauliflower Crust) - Make Your Own Pizza

$13Cauliflower crust, tomato sauce and cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000
Large 14 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza
00000

Large 14 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza

$17.50Traditional Thick Crust, Tomato Sauce and Cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000
00000

Small 10 Inch (Gluten Free Crust) - Make Your Own Pizza

$13Gluten Free crust, tomato sauce and cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000
Medium 12 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza
00000

Medium 12 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza

$14.50Traditional Thick Crust, Tomato Sauce and Cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000
X-Large 16 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza
00000

X-Large 16 Inch - Make Your Own Pizza

$20Traditional Thick Crust, Tomato Sauce and Cheese. Add your favorite toppings.

00000

Specialty Pizzas

Our Specialty Pizzas are Uniquely Created with Taste in Mind. Deletions are Okay. No Substitutions or Adding Toppings

Tony Salerno's Special
10001

Tony Salerno's Special

Sausage, Mushroom, Onion, Green Pepper, and PepperoniS (10 inch) $17M (12 inch) $23L (14 inch) $27XL (16 inch) $31

10001
00000

The Barn Yard

Sausage, Pepperoni, Chicken, and BaconS (10 inch) $16M (12 inch) $21L (14 inch) $25XL (16 inch) $29

00000
00000

Bruschetta Bocconcini

Our Delicious Bruschetta with Fresh Mozzarella On an Ultra Thin CrustS (10 inch) $13M (12 inch) $18L (14 inch) $21XL (16 inch) $24

00000
Taco Pizza
00000

Taco Pizza

Pizza Sauce, Ground Beef and Jalapenos Topped with Lettuce, Tomato, Onion, Avocado, and Cheddar Cheese On a Thin Crust.S (10 inch) $17M (12 inch) $23L (14 inch) $27XL (16 inch) $31

00000
00000

Hawaiian Pizza

BBQ sauce, ham, and pineapple on thin crustS (10 inch) $13M (12 inch) $18L (14 inch) $21XL (16 inch) $24

00000
00000

Rob's Choice Pizza

Chicken, Artichoke, Black Olives, and BaconS (10 inch) $16M (12 inch) $21L (14 inch) $25XL (16 inch) $29

00000
00000

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$9.50served with lettuce, tomato, and buffalo sauce

00000
00000

Veggie Special

artichoke, black olives, zucchini, onion, and mushroom on thin crustS (10 inch) $17M (12 inch) $23L (14 inch) $27XL (16 inch) $31

00000
00000

The Bull & Bear

Italian Beef & Hot Giardiniera on a Thin CrustS (10 inch) $15M (12 inch) $20L (14 inch) $24XL (16 inch) $28

00000
00000

Margherita Pizza

Tomato, Basil, and Fresh Mozzarella on a Thin CrustS (10 inch) $13M (12 inch) $18L (14 inch) $21XL (16 inch) $24

00000

Panzerotti & Calzone

Fillings
Anchovies, Bacon, Canadian Bacon, Chicken, Ground Beef, Ham, Italian Beef, Pepperoni, Sausage, Artichoke, Black Olives, Green Olives, Green Peppers, Ham, Hot Giardiniera, Jalapenos, Mushroom, Onions, Pineapple, Ricotta Cheese, Spinach, Tomatoes, Zucchini

Calzone
00000

Calzone

$7we take our specialty dough and stuff it with a blend of cheeses and our homemade marinara sauce and bake it to perfection

add your favorite fillings (max 5)
regular $1 each premium $1.50 each

00000
Panzerotti "As Big As Your Head"
00000

Panzerotti "As Big As Your Head"

$7a 12" creation made from our signature dough, stuffed with a blend of cheeses and our homemade marinara sauce and then deep fried to perfection

add your favorite fillings (max 5)
regular $1 each premium $1.50 each

00000

Chicken Wings

Mounds of Premium Wings, Cooked to Perfection and Smothered in the Sauce of Your choice (approx. 7 Wings per Order)

00000

Wings- Sweet Thai Chili

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
00000

Wings- Garlic Parmesan

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
Wings- Hot Buffalo
00000

Wings- Hot Buffalo

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
00000

Wings- Honey BBQ

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
00000

Wings- Mango Habanero (Hot!)

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
00000

Wings- Teriyaki

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
Wings- Mild Buffalo
00000

Wings- Mild Buffalo

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
Wings- Blazing Hot!
00000

Wings- Blazing Hot!

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000
00000

Wings- BBQ

$9.50premium wings, cooked to perfection and smothered in the sauce of your choice (approx. 7 wings per serving)

00000

Specialty Wings

Mounds of Premium Wings, Cooked to Perfection and Smothered in the Sauce of Your choice (approx. 7 Wings per Order)

Vesuvio Wings
00000

Vesuvio Wings

$9.50Served in a White Wine & Herb Sauce

00000
Tequila Wings
00000

Tequila Wings

$9.50Grilled & Sauteed in Tequila & Lime

00000

Sandwiches & Paninis

Served with Fries or House Salad. Waffle Fries Add $2.00 | Onion Rings Add $3.00 | Sandwich Additions: Cheese $1.00 | Hot Peppers $1.00 |Sweet Peppers $1.00.

00000

Italian Gyros

$9.50Our Homemade Italian Sausage Thinly Sliced and Served Over Pita and Topped with Red Onion and Our Own Italian Style Tzatziki Sauce

00000
Chicken BLT Ranch Wrap
00000

Chicken BLT Ranch Wrap

$9.50Cubed Grilled Chicken, Bacon, Lettuce & Tomatoes Drizzled with Ranch Dressing in a Flour Tortilla.

00000
00000

Buffalo Chicken Sandwich

$9.50served with lettuce, tomato, and buffalo sauce

00000
Magoo's "Special" Beef
00000

Magoo's "Special" Beef

$9.50Oven Baked and Served Open Face with Peppers, Grilled Onion, Mozzarella and Marinara on the Side.

00000
Italian Meatball
00000

Italian Meatball

$9Smothered in Marinara Sauce

00000
The Combo
00000

The Combo

$10.50Traditional Italian Sausage and Sliced Beef with Sweet Peppers.

00000
00000

Grilled Tuscan Panini

$9.50A Grilled Chicken Breast, Provolone Cheese, Roasted Red Peppers, Artichoke Hearts, Tomatoes, and Basil Pesto Mayo.

00000
Chicago Style Footlong
00000

Chicago Style Footlong

$6All Beef Footlong Hot Dog Topped with Mustard, Onion, Tomatoes, and Relish

00000
00000

Pulled Pork

$9.50Tender Hand Pulled Pork in Our Tennessee Spices Tossed in Apple Bourbon BBQ Sauce and Topped with Cheddar Jack Cheese on a Specialty Roll.

00000
00000

Blackened Chicken

$9.50Cajun Chicken Breast, Pepper Jack Cheese with Avocado & Lime Mayo.

00000
00000

Buffalo Chicken Wrap

$9.50served with lettuce, tomato, and buffalo sauce

00000
Italian Beef Sandwich
00000

Italian Beef Sandwich

$8.50

00000
00000

Italian Sausage

$8.50Topped with Marinara or Au Jus.

00000
00000

Turkey Avocado Club

$10.50Premium Turkey Breast Piled High with Avocado, Bacon, Lettuce, and Tomato on Wheat Bread.

00000
00000

Grilled Italiano Panini

$9.50Genoa Salami, Imported Mortadella, Ham, Provolone Cheese, Lettuce, Tomatoes, Onions, and Italian Dressing.

00000

Burgers

Served with fries or house salad. Waffle fries add $2.00 | onion rings add $3.00 | Burger Additions: Avocado $2.00 | Bacon $1.00 | Cheese $1.00 | Grilled Onions $1.00 | Over-Easy Egg $1, Sauteed Mushrooms $1.00.

Whiskey Hill BBQ Pork Cheddar & Bacon Burger
00000

Whiskey Hill BBQ Pork Cheddar & Bacon Burger

$12.50our juicy 1/2 lb. Angus burger topped with pulled pork and our whiskey hill bbq sauce, bacon, & cheddar cheese topped with onion straws

00000
All American Burger
00000

All American Burger

$10.50Our juicy 1/2 lb. Angus burger served with American cheese, lettuce, tomato, and onion.

00000
Turkey & Avocado Burger
00000

Turkey & Avocado Burger

$11Premium Turkey burger served with avocado, American cheese, lettuce, tomato, & onion.

00000
10001

Fatty Magoo Burger

$10.50Our juicy 1/2 lb. Angus burger with grilled onions, bacon, and American cheese, drizzled with bleu cheese dressing.

10001
00000

Jalapeño Burger

$11Our juicy 1/2 lb. Angus burger served with fresh sliced jalapenos, Pepper Jack cheese, and chipotle ranch.

00000

Entrees

Served with House Salad Substitute Soup for $1.00 more.

The Parmigiana
00000

The Parmigiana

$15Chicken Breast Breaded and Baked with Our Red Sauce and Mozzarella and Parmesan Cheese, Served with Side of Mostaccioli Marinara.

00000
Shrimp Dinner
00000

Shrimp Dinner

$17Breaded Jumbo Butterfly Shrimp and Served with Broccoli.

00000
"Healthy Magoo" Platter
00000

"Healthy Magoo" Platter

$14.50Portioned Caprese Salad Served with Choice of Sauteed Broccoli or Spinach and Two Chicken Breasts (Grilled or Blackened).

00000
00000

Quesadilla- Chicken

$12Flour Tortilla Stuffed with Chicken, Cheese, Red Peppers, Mushrooms, & Onion.

00000
00000

Quesadilla- Veggie

$9flour tortilla stuffed with cheese, red peppers, mushrooms, & onion

00000
Chicken Vesuvio
00000

Chicken Vesuvio

$15Chicken Breast Sauteed in Garlic, White Wine Sauce & Spices. Served with Potato Wedges.

00000
00000

Chicago Joe's Chicken

$14.50Baked Boneless Chicken Breast Lightly Breaded and Topped with Fresh Bruschetta. Served over Fettuccine Tossed in Extra Virgin Olive Oil.

00000
Tacos
00000

Tacos

Your Choice of 3 Chicken, Steak, or Fish in a Flour Tortilla Topped with Pico de Gallo.

00000
00000

Quesadilla- Grilled Steak

$15flour tortilla stuffed with grilled steak, cheese, red peppers, mushrooms, & onion

00000

Salerno's Signature Dishes

Our Family's homemade sauces and dishes that made us popular for years. Served with House Salad. Substitute Soup for $1.00 more.

Mama's Meat Lasagna
00000

Mama's Meat Lasagna

$14Of Course it's Homemade.

00000
Vodka Pasta
00000

Vodka Pasta

$13Rigatoni in a Garlic Cream and Tomato Sauce Flavored with Vodka.

00000
00000

Homemade Ravioli

$12Ravioli Stuffed with Your Choice of Meat or Cheese. Covered with Marinara Sauce.

00000
Baked Sausage Paisano
00000

Baked Sausage Paisano

$14.50Rigatoni in Our Signature Vodka Sauce with Slices of Homemade Italian Sausage and Mushrooms Covered with Mozzarella Cheese.

00000

"Make Your Own" Pasta

Served with a House Salad. Substitute Soup for $1.00 more. Additions: Shrimp $5.00 | Meatballs, Sausage or Chicken $4.00 | Broccoli $2.00. *Have it Baked with Meat Sauce, Ricotta & Mozzarella add $3.00. Gluten Free (Spaghetti or Rigatoni) Available add $3.00.

MYO Pasta Entree
00000

MYO Pasta Entree

00000

Kids Dishes

Your Choice $6.50 (kids 10 and under only)
includes soft drink or milk

00000

Cheese Pizza

$6.50pepperoni or sausage toppings
(.75 cents each)

00000
00000

Hot Dog with Fries

$6.50hot dog with ketchup, relish and a pickle

00000
00000

Grilled Cheese with Fries

$6.50

00000
00000

Chicken Tenders with Fries

$6.50with BBQ, honey mustard or ranch dipping sauce

00000
00000

Mac N Cheese

$6.50

00000
00000

Sunday Gravy

$6.50Spaghetti or Mostaccoli with a Meatball or Sausage

00000

Signature Desserts

00000

Hazelnut Truffle

$7a core of dark chocolate embraced with hazelnut gelato covered with praline hazelnut and meringue

00000
00000

Cookie Skillet

$6.50homemade chocolate chip cookie dough topped with vanilla ice cream and drizzled with chocolate & caramel sauce

00000
00000

Double Chocolate Cake

$7

00000

* We reserve the right to limit quantities - Prices subject to change without notice *

Made with by Popmenu
  • R. Salerno's Restaurant Group
Fatty Magoo's Bar & Eatery
Website Accessibility Assistance
Opens in a new windowOpens an external siteOpens an external site in a new window